Pakistan may nix port deal with PSA, China to benefit?

Sunday, 14 November 2010 20:56 -     - {{hitsCtrl.values.hits}}

  • Provincial government to challenge port deal in court
  • PSA fails to bring in trade
  • Security concerns discourage trade

ISLAMABAD (Reuters) - The head of Pakistan’s Baluchistan province pledged last week to challenge in the courts what he said was a “one-sided” deal with a Singapore company to run a strategic harbour in Gwadar port.

Authorities dismissed any notion that the port would be handed to Chinese control because of its substantial investment. But analysts suspect China would push for a major say over the port to back its bid to expand its influence in the Indian Ocean.

Pakistan, struggling to revive its debt-hit economy, is keen to become a conduit for trade to landlocked Afghanistan and Central Asia. It has three major ports -- Gwadar in Baluchistan and two at Karachi, 450 km (280 miles) to the east.

As initially envisaged, former president Pervez Musharraf’s government gave management and operational control of the deep-sea port to Singapore’s PSA International Ltd [PSAIN.UL] in February 2007 for 40 years.

But the chief minister of the government of Baluchistan, the southwestern province where Gawdar port is located, said he would seek its cancellation by the Supreme Court this month.

“After consultation with legal experts and law ministry, we have decided that we will go to the court this month and seek its cancellation,” Nawab Mohammad Aslam Raisani said in an interview in Islamabad. “It’s a one-sided agreement. It’s our land. It’s our port and we should run it.”

He said PSA International Ltd had neither brought in trade nor expanded the port. But there were no plans to hand the port to China. “Why can we not operate it ourselves? We have trained people.”

PSA, which runs ports around the world and is owned by state wealth fund Temasek Holdings, declined comment.

Gwadar port handled about $700 million in cargo in 2009, less than half of its cargo capacity, a port and shipping ministry official said. He said the company had made no investment despite an agreement to invest $525 million over five years.

Pakistan gets only 9 percent of the port’s total revenue.

Slow business also caused suspension of planned $1.5 billion investment by a Chinese company, Tianjin Zhongbei Harbour Engineering, he said.

In September, Pakistan’s naval chief asked the government to review the contract for the same reasons.

Gwadar, 70 km (45 miles) east of the Iranian border and on the doorstep of Gulf shipping lanes, was conceived over a decade ago with hopes it would handle transhipment traffic for the Gulf.

A regional maritime industry source said a failure to develop infrastructure by the port and check security discouraged trade.

Under the agreement, the Baluchistan government, which has been battling a decades-old low-level revolt by nationalists for provincial autonomy, was to develop a free-zone for warehouses and export processing zone and establish road and rail links.

The central government, led by Prime Minister Yusuf Raza Gilani, appears unwilling to defend the contract with PSA.

“I don’t think we will. We can only prove that we followed the due process at the time of awarding the contract,” a senior government official said.

Abu Dhabi buys $2.1bn stake in Australian port

Abu Dhabi Investment Authority (ADIA), one of the world’s largest sovereign wealth funds, has bought a minority stake in Australia’s Port of Brisbane in a deal worth A$2.1 billion, ($2.11 billion) the Queensland government said in a statement.

ADIA was part of the Q Port Holdings consortium that included major stakeholders Global Infrastructure Partners, Industry Funds Management (IFM) and funds managed by QIC Limited that will take ownership of the port under a 99-year lease.

ADIA, through its wholly-owned subsidiary Tawreed Investments, took a 19 percent stake in the port while the remaining three funds hold a 27 percent stake each.

‘This is a quality group of investors with the skill and balance sheet to ensure the future development of the port. It includes leading players in port and airport operations and two of Australia’s largest superannuation fund managers,’ Andrew Fraser, treasurer and minister for employment & economic development, Queensland said in the statement.

Collectively, the consortium has interests in port terminals across eight countries and two of them, IFM and QIC are shareholders in the Brisbane Airport.

ADIA, which has assets of $500 billion to $700 billion, holds stakes in London’s Gatwick Airport and a long-term lease on Chicago’s parking meters, among other high profile investments globally.

In March this year, ADIA published its first annual review providing details of its 2009 global portfolio that includes investments in more than two dozen asset classes and sub-categories.

ADIA’s funds returned 6.5 percent on an annualised basis, over a 20-year period as of December 31, 2009.  On the same basis, the fund returned 8 percent over a 30-year period, it said in the review.

At least 46 percent of the fund’s portfolio in 2009 was allocated to equities, with a minimum of 35 percent in developed markets and at least 10 percent in emerging markets. - Reuters