OTTAWA (Reuters): Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau on Wednesday accepted a watchdog’s report that he breached ethics rules by trying to influence a corporate legal case but refused to apologise, saying he had been trying to defend jobs.
Canada's Prime Minister
Justin Trudeau – Reuters
Independent ethics commissioner Mario Dion said Trudeau and his team attempted last year to undermine a decision by federal prosecutors that construction company SNC-Lavalin Group Inc should face a corruption trial.
Dion’s scathing 58-page assessment could hurt Trudeau’s chances of retaining power in a general election in October.
“I fully accept this report ... I take full responsibility. The buck stops with the prime minister,” said Trudeau, adding that he nevertheless disagreed with some of Dion’s conclusions.
The scandal over SNC-Lavalin, which erupted in early February, battered Trudeau’s image as a youthful progressive at the helm of a government that had vowed to be open and transparent. He is the first Canadian prime minister found to have broken federal ethics rules.
The firm, a major employer in the politically important province of Quebec, wanted to take advantage of a 2018 law allowing it to escape with a fine rather than be prosecuted for bribing officials in Libya.
Trudeau has admitted he tried last year to persuade former Justice Minister Jody Wilson-Raybould to reconsider the prosecutor’s decision to press ahead with a trial.
“What we did over the past year wasn’t good enough. But at the same time I can’t apologise for standing up for Canadian jobs,” he told a televised news conference in Niagara-on-the-Lake, Ontario.
The affair marked the low point of Trudeau’s almost four-year tenure and prompted the resignation of two high-profile female cabinet ministers, his closest personal aide Gerry Butts, and the head of the federal bureaucracy.
The case proved politically harmful and Trudeau’s Liberals trailed the official opposition Conservatives for several months in opinion polls ahead of the election that will determine whether or not Trudeau stays in power. Recent surveys, however, showed the center-left Liberals edging in front of their right-leaning rivals.
Dion found Trudeau had contravened conflict of interest rules forbidding public office holders from trying to improperly further another person’s private interests.
“Because SNC‑Lavalin overwhelmingly stood to benefit from Ms. Wilson-Raybould’s intervention, I have no doubt that the result of Mr. Trudeau’s influence would have furthered SNC-Lavalin’s interests. The actions that sought to further these interests were improper,” he added.
Wilson-Raybould refused to overrule the prosecutor’s decision, and was demoted in a cabinet shuffle in January. She resigned the next month.
Wilson-Raybould has been particularly critical of the role played by Butts, who has rejoined the prime minister’s team to focus on the election. Trudeau sidestepped questions as to whether he would fire Butts and other senior aides.
Conservative leader Andrew Scheer described Trudeau’s behaviour as “unforgivable” and said a police investigation was warranted.
“He has stated so many falsehoods that no one can believe anything he says,” Scheer told a televised news conference in Regina, Saskatchewan.
He did not repeat earlier calls for Trudeau to step down, saying Canadians should vote him out of office on 21 October.
“For sure the timing is going to be very difficult for the current government. The information is ... damning,” University of Ottawa law professor Jennifer Quaid told the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation.
The report marks the second time Trudeau has fallen afoul of conflict of interest rules. In December 2017, former ethics commissioner Mary Dawson said Trudeau acted wrongly by accepting a vacation on the Aga Khan’s private island.
On that occasion, Trudeau apologised.