Home / Opinion and Issues/ Milinda’s National Service proposal

Milinda’s National Service proposal


Comments / {{hitsCtrl.values.hits}} Views / Tuesday, 28 May 2019 00:00


Sri Lanka was a complex crisis even before the Easter Sunday suicide attacks. Now, in the wake of the Easter Sunday attacks, the country has plunged into a deeper and bigger crisis, which is more complex than it was before. 

Milinda Moragoda has proposed that the Government should introduce compulsory military service. In a statement he said: “Sri Lanka’s fractured society and lack of social cohesion make it essential that radical solutions be implemented for what at present appears to be an intractable problem.” 

It may be correct, but is his suggestion the correct way to get back from the present crisis? Our leaders need to unite and implement measures that can be regenerated on an immediate basis. In the context of the political corruption cesspit Sri Lanka has fallen into, this adage quite deservingly applies it. But, without a nationwide will and lack of public activism to the required level to change the political culture, the corrupt political system never ends. 

The term National Service comes from the United Kingdom’s National Service (Armed Forces) Act 1939. Many young people spent one or more years in such programmes. Compulsory military service typically requires all male citizens to enrol for one or two years, usually at age 18, for voluntary National Service with basic military training. 

This kind of system whereby the state requires all men to serve a period in the armed forces began in Prussia in the 18th century. It was developed by Napoleon in France. Thereafter, the “call-up” spread throughout continental Europe, historical studies show. In the 1980s, during the term of the UNP, legislation to provide for manpower mobilisation was introduced by the then Youth Affairs Ministry. The Mobilisation and Supplementary Forces Act referred to as the ‘Law of Compulsory Conscription in Sri Lanka; is already in place.

Many countries have made it mandatory for all men to serve in the military for a specific period of time. About 26 countries have made military service compulsory. Some countries, like Israel, have made it mandatory for both women to enrol in mandatory military service. However, we should not forget in 1994, after a lawsuit against the Israeli Defence Army by Alice Miller for not being allowed to fly a plane, women can now engage in all combat positions. 

Mandatory military service is exempt for nursing and expectant mothers. Furthermore, there are some people who are excluded from the service due to their religious affiliations. Mandatory military service for all citizens could be an explanation for Israel being among the countries that spend most on military per capita. 

As Moragoda informed us in his statement, implementing a National Service Policy is expensive for any country and will require serious attention and planning. Military training will be good in terms of discipline, but the top layers of the military are undisciplined. Best example is military vehicles. Road rules do not apply to powerful officers. In the morning military school buses use the opposite lane on roads. How can we hand over our youth to them? The people heading the armed forces have to be disciplined members of society before such a drastic step is taken or even considered. 

According to Milinda’s proposal, this programme should be implemented comprehensively and apply to all Sri Lankans regardless of social position, ethnic origin or religious background. Fulfilling National Service requirements should be a prerequisite for recruitment to any public service job. Can anyone trust their babies will be in the same camp with super power members, eat camp food? Everyone has experienced politicians’ families getting jobs. Sometimes making everyone undergo military training will increase the number of criminals in the country. What is the judgement on conscription? Difficult to say, because the reaction was a mix. Moragoda, your suggestion has weight, but Sri Lanka is a land like no other. 

– Sahamindra Wattegedara


Share This Article

Facebook Twitter


DISCLAIMER:

1. All comments will be moderated by the Daily FT Web Editor.

2. Comments that are abusive, obscene, incendiary, defamatory or irrelevant will not be published.

3. We may remove hyperlinks within comments.

4. Kindly use a genuine email ID and provide your name.

5. Spamming the comments section under different user names may result in being blacklisted.

COMMENTS

Today's Columnists

China’s virus shutdown will hurt growth abroad

Friday, 28 February 2020

Many affluent Chinese fearful of being infected by the coronavirus and being quarantined by the State are staying home. Many companies and countries around the world are linked to the Chinese economy, which is likely to have far-reaching consequences


The reality of the system

Friday, 28 February 2020

The whole system of the country which has been crumbling is now on the verge of near collapse. The political regime, bureaucracy, intellectuals and the society in general did not have a sufficiently developed political imagination to understand the n


Writing on the wall

Thursday, 27 February 2020

Quick! Pick between reading this and opting to do something that really makes you happy. I suspect 99% of you would be more fulfilled getting to work half-an-hour earlier, going to market or school sooner than later, or simply goofing off at home or


Geneva: Right cause, wrong tactics

Thursday, 27 February 2020

The Geneva 2015 resolution is a hidden tripwire linked to a maze of claymore mines, some buried, some planted in ditches, others nested in trees. When this article appears, Sri Lanka may have nudged that tripwire. There was another, smarter, safer wa


Columnists More