Home / FT View/ Budget focus

Budget focus


Comments / {{hitsCtrl.values.hits}} Views / Thursday, 22 February 2018 00:00


Even though the political fallout of the Local Government elections has begun to ebb, the reasons for it should not be allowed to be forgotten by lawmakers. As the President and the Prime Minister seek to fast-track implementation of reforms and meet public expectations, there are several key points that must be hardcoded into any policy making process. The first is Budget formulation, and the second is staying true to fiscal consolidation.  

As prominent economist and advisor to the Finance Ministry Dr. Razeen Sally, in a scathing evaluation of the reasons behind the Government’s loss pointed out this week, the economic returns that the public expected when they elected the coalition in 2015 had failed to materialise. Worse, the process was hamstrung by bad appointments and worse policy implementation. In Dr. Sally’s estimation, one of the major points that need to be radically changed was the Budget formulation process of Sri Lanka. 

Currently, various Ministries send in their wish lists, mostly consisting of wish lists of Ministers, to the Treasury, which is then hammered down into a series of policies that are then encased in the Budget and presented to Parliament. This, as Dr. Sally eloquently pointed out, was a ‘dog’s breakfast’ that had little to do with managing the overall economic health of the country or fermenting sustainable development. It has become so ad hoc and illogical, that even the public scarcely pays attention to the Budget, because they know that few of the policies actually get implemented. 

Verité Research, in a recent evaluation of the 2017 Budget proposals, found that less than half of them had been implemented, and transparency of the process was less than satisfactory. A separate Open Budget Survey showed that Sri Lanka was behind all its South Asian compatriots, with the exception of Bangladesh, on Budget formulation and transparency, leaving a huge amount of leeway for the government to do discretionary spending. These lapses in the Budget-making process allow for ill-judged policies, such as the tab-giving to all teachers and schoolchildren, which would have wasted colossal amounts of public funds. Fortunately, the President stopped the effort recently, after Cabinet approved purchasing each tab for Rs. 27,000. 

Many of the proposals in Budgets are done without a cost-benefit analysis, and leave room for corruption and knee-jerk policymaking to creep in because public interest is not at the heart of policymaking.  This is worsened at the tail-end of a political term when Governments, sensing that they are not as popular as they wish, are tempted to garner votes by increasing spending. This kind of fiscal spending cannot be allowed in Sri Lanka, as the Central Bank has already warned. 

As Dr. Sally noted, a crucial step mulled by the Finance Minister is to have the Treasury draw up a draft Budget in the middle of the year, which would lay out the larger targets of the Government in terms of revenue, expenditure and debt servicing, and then invite the various ministries to send in their proposals with a cost-benefit analysis. Such a measure is long overdue and to be applauded, because it would then take the guesswork out of Budget formulation, simplify it, and ensure that what is laid out every November is actually implemented. This is a huge leap in the right direction.  


Share This Article


DISCLAIMER:

1. All comments will be moderated by the Daily FT Web Editor.

2. Comments that are abusive, obscene, incendiary, defamatory or irrelevant will not be published.

3. We may remove hyperlinks within comments.

4. Kindly use a genuine email ID and provide your name.

5. Spamming the comments section under different user names may result in being blacklisted.

COMMENTS

Today's Columnists

Craving a world with free migration of Homo sapiens

Monday, 18 June 2018

During the discussion time following the presentation of a paper by former diplomat Tamara Kunanayakam on the invasion of Sri Lanka’s economic policymaking by neoliberal economic thinkers two weeks ago, Colombo University’s economics don Lalithas


Sigmoid Curve and Sri Lanka: Significant signals

Monday, 18 June 2018

Sri Lanka, often named as the ‘Wonder of Asia,’ has many citizens wondering what is going on.


Refuse and recuse in Cloud-Cuckoo-Land

Friday, 15 June 2018

I had a dream. That there were monsters ruling the land in the disguise of being military champions. But then some knights in slightly tarnished armour rode to the nation’s defence and liberated us from our saviours. And all was well again. At leas


Floods, drought and disasters

Thursday, 14 June 2018

The Yahapalana Government has been singularly unfortunate in having to face many natural and manmade disasters during their regime.Almost every year many citizens have to undergo the consequences of floods in certain parts of the country whereas ther


Columnists More