Home / Front Page/ SC holds that HRC recommendations can be challenged in Writ application

SC holds that HRC recommendations can be challenged in Writ application


Comments / {{hitsCtrl.values.hits}} Views / Tuesday, 11 July 2017 00:22


By S.S. Selvanayagam

In a landmark judgment, the Supreme Court held that the recommendations of the Human Rights Commission can be challenged in a Writ application.

Justice Sisira J. De Abrew with Justices Upaly Abeyrathne and Nalin Perera agreeing in his judgment upheld the appeal filed by Sri Lanka Telecom PLC.

Appellant Sri Lanka Telecom appealed to the Supreme Court challenging the judgment of the Court of Appeal.

The Court of Appeal in its judgment had held that an adverse recommendation issued by the Human Rights Commission (HRC) in terms of the HRC Act could not be challenged and could not be reviewed by the Court of Appeal in Writ proceedings for judicial review.

Appellant Sri Lanka Telecom cited the Human Rights Commission, its members, M.M.M. Zaheed and others as Respondents. Sanjeeva Jayawardena PC with Pubudini Wicremaratne appeared for Sri Lanka Telecom. Senior Deputy Solicitor General appeared for the HRC. W. Dayaratne PC appeared for Zaheed. 

The Supreme Court set aside the judgment of the Court of Appeal and upheld the argument of Sri Lanka Telecom that even a pure recommendation, as opposed to a final order or decision, the recommendation and report of HRC could be challenged in a Writ application as the law pertaining to Writ applications had evolved very greatly in the modern day and that even incidental orders which are not final orders and only recommendations of a tribunal could be challenged in a Writ application if they represent a step in a statutory process and held the potential of affecting the rights of a citizen.

The Supreme Court held that a recommendation made by the HRC generate an affectation of rights and interests and is therefore clearly justifiable and can be complained against in a Writ application.

The Supreme Court also held that whenever any body of persons having legal authority to determine questions affecting the rights of citizens, and whenever the legislature entrusts to anyone other than the superior courts, the power of imposing an obligation upon individuals, and which leads to an affectation of rights, the courts ought to exercise as widely as they can, the power of controlling those bodies if they attempted to make exceed their jurisdiction, even if that decision does not affect the rights immediately. This principle applies not merely to statutory bodies.

Accordingly the Supreme Court reversed the judgment of the Court of Appeal.


Share This Article

Facebook Twitter


DISCLAIMER:

1. All comments will be moderated by the Daily FT Web Editor.

2. Comments that are abusive, obscene, incendiary, defamatory or irrelevant will not be published.

3. We may remove hyperlinks within comments.

4. Kindly use a genuine email ID and provide your name.

5. Spamming the comments section under different user names may result in being blacklisted.

COMMENTS

Today's Columnists

Reflections on President Gotabaya Rajapaksa

Monday, 16 December 2019

It is the honeymoon period, where nice things are being said about the new President, but things will change. That’s the way it is always. The little mumbles of those who did not get what they wanted will become loud rumbles. The UNP will be lookin


Swiss Embassy employee’s case: A critique

Monday, 16 December 2019

The case of the alleged abduction and harassment of the Swiss Embassy employee is causing concerns at the level of bilateral diplomatic relations. The details of the episode that have come out into the open indicate several involvements of a suspicio


Creed of breeding leaders: Reflections on ‘Mind Before Action’

Monday, 16 December 2019

The new shift of the national leadership has ignited a ray of optimism of what Sri Lanka can become with its untapped talent. As Peter Drucker said, there are not good or bad institutions, but either well-managed or ill-managed ones. This is relevant


Sri Lanka’s worst air disaster

Monday, 16 December 2019

It was December 1974 and the Hajj was in full swing. The Hajj has been called the greatest pilgrimage movement in the world, with millions of devout Muslims travelling to Mecca every year. It is a requirement for every Muslim to accomplish the Hajj a


Columnists More